TIP #157
,
Argument expansion with Leading {expand}, followed by TIP
#293,
Argument expansion with Leading {*}, led to the introduction of the
{*} syntax in Tcl version
8.5. TIP
#144 was subsequently withdrawn.
Voting results:
Message-id: <200310201720.h9KHKZE28063@observ.crd.ge.COM>
To: tcl-core@lists.sourceforge.net
Date: Mon, 20 Oct 2003 13:20:35 -0400
Subject: [TCLCORE] VOTE RESULTS: TIPs #156 and #157
The deadline for voting on TIPs #156 and #157 is now past.
Ballots received are listed below; to verify each ballot,
one can view the URL:
http://sourceforge.net/mailarchive/message.php?msg_id=N
where N is the message number.
Member Message 156 157(8.5) 157(9.0)
-----------------------------------------------------
DeJong 6256062 PRESENT NO YES
Fellows 6256063 YES NO PRESENT
Harrison ------------- absent --------------
Hipp 6284469 YES YES YES
Hobbs 6241531 (*) NO NO
Howlett 6282872 PRESENT NO NO
Ingham 6274059 PRESENT YES YES
Kenny 6241529 YES YES YES
Kupries 6284468 YES YES YES
Lehenbauer ------------- absent --------------
McLennan 6273145 PRESENT YES YES(**)
Nijtmans 6288994 YES YES YES
Ousterhout 6241533 (*) YES YES
Porter 6281712 YES YES YES
Welch ------------- absent --------------
(*) denotes a ballot received that did not include a vote for
the given TIP. PRESENT is assumed.
(**) Poster did not explicitly cast 8.5 and 9.0 ballots, but
intent was abundantly clear from the discussion.
Totals:
TIP #156: 6 YES, 0 NO, 6 PRESENT
TIP #157 (8.5): 8 YES, 4 NO
TIP #157 (9.0): 9 YES, 2 NO, 1 PRESENT
TIP #156 passes.
TIP #157 passes for implementation in 8.5.
I would like to take this opportunity to thank all parties for their
patience in dealing with the highly contentious TIP #157. It is
without doubt a compromise that fits nobody's ideal. (Alas, the
essence of compromise is that everyone comes out a little bit
dissatisfied.) I hope that, now that the vote is past, we can put
the differences behind us and move forward to implementing it.
